Dichotomous table for gallers on Sinapis
(incl. Coincya)
by Hans Roskam
1a On parts above ground => 5
1b On roots or root collar => 2
2a Galls on roots => 3
2b Whitish, rotund, one-chambered swellings on root collar, up to about 6 mm long, sometimes with several and ± coalescing. Each chamber containing a single white larva. S. alba, arvensis: Ceutorhynchus assimilis
3a Malformations mainly on lateral roots, only exceptionally more than 5 mm long and 3 mm wide => 4
3b Galls of very variable size, conspicuous on main- lateral roots; spindle-shaped to cylindrical, usually more than 10 mm, up to even 20 mm long and about 4–8 mm wide; sometimes encroaching from the main root onto the branchings, also coalesced into larger groups; succulent. Inside are masses of minute spores. “Clubroot”. S. alba, arvensis & subsp. allionii: Plasmodiophora brassicae
4a Roots with small nodular to elongate cylindrical, usually many swellings bearing several lateral roots. S. alba, arvensis: Meloidogyne hapla
4b Outside of roots unchanged; inside with giant cells, bearing poppy seed-sized white to brown cysts. S. alba, arvensis: Heterodera sp.
= Scattered reports of damage by H. schachtii, H. trifolii and H. cruciferae
5a Malformations on inflorescences, flowers or siliques => 16
5b Galls on leaves, axial buds or stems, in the latter case sometimes encroaching onto inflorescences => 6
6a Gall formations ± delimited in expansion, usually only on parts of infected organs => 10
6b Malformations of irregular shape and expansion; usually on various organs => 7
7a On organs of ± fully developed plants => 8
7b Young plants severely stunted and disfigured. Petioles and main venation as well as shoots stunted, pale green, spongy. S. alba, arvensis: Ditylenchus dipsaci
8a The inducers develop on the outside of mostly terminal malformations => 9
8b Stem slightly swollen to large extent. In the increased pith of the ± disfigured, stunted and sometimes distorted plants live several beetle larvae. S. arvensis: Ceutorhynchus napi
9a Axis of the tips of vegetative- or developing flowering shoots ± stunted; the inserted organs clustered, development stunted. Leaf blades curved, curled. Flower buds or flowers variously disfigured. S. alba, arvensis: Brevicoryne brassicae
9b Stem locally stunted, sometimes bent; the inserted leaves clustered; the leaf blade arched, at the infestation site ± curled and discoloured deep green. S. alba, arvensis: Philaenus spumarius
10a Galls on well-developed stems or leaves => 11
10b Terminal, also lateral shoots, and axillary buds severely stunted in longitudinal growth. Leaves clustered, the inner ones developing into rosette- to bud-like galls, especially thickened at base. Containing several whitish to pale yellow, jumping larvae. S. alba, arvensis: Contarinia nasturtii
11a Malformations caused by fungi => 15
11b Malformations caused by animals => 12
12a Causers inside entirely deep green galls => 14
12b Causers develop outside the malformations => 13
13a Leaf blade with small, localised swellings. S. arvensis: Inducer unidentified – ? psyllid
13b Leaf blade ± folded, or variously deflected or bent upwards at margin, usually pale green, sometimes reddish marbled. S. alba, arvensis: Brevicoryne brassicae
= Lipaphis erysimi, which is facultatively cecidogenic on several crucifers, also occurs on Sinapis.
14a Galls flat spindle-shaped, 10–15 mm long; mainly on midrib, midrib or petioles, occasionally on stems. Containing a single larva. S. alba, arvensis: Ceutorhynchus chalybaeus
14b Galls flat rotund-oval, including the finer venation situated in the leaf blade. S. arvensis: Ceutorhynchus leprieuri
15a Leaf blade on underside with rotund bulges, up to 10 mm wide, or young stem parts ± spindle-shaped, often expanded, which are at first glossy, porcelain-like, later rupturing and with mealy dusted sori. S. arvensis, rarely S. alba: Albugo candida s. lat.
15b Leaf blade with weak bladder-like swellings; young stem sometimes with conspicuous, usually one-sided, ± distorted bulge-like swellings, soon covered with a whitish down of branched conidiophores. S. alba & subsp. dissecta, arvensis & subsp. allionii: Hyaloperonospora brassicae
16a Malformations on inflorescences or flowers => 17
16b Siliques usually only insignificantly stunted and disfigured; ± sterile, early (prematurely) maturing; contain several white larvae. S. alba, arvensis: Dasineura napi
17a Malformations caused by fungi => 22
17b Malformations caused by other inducers => 18
18a Galls on single or several flowers of inflorescences that are not additionally conspicuously stunted => 21
18b Axis usually ± stunted with clustered flower buds => 19
19a Malformations not abnormally pubescent => 20
19b Calyx little changed; inner flower parts transformed into ± leaf-like organs or greened; infected parts excessively pubescent. S. arvensis: Unidentified gall mite
20a Flower buds clustered on the stunted, hardly swollen axial parts. Containing several white to pale yellow jumping larvae. S. alba, arvensis: Contarinia nasturtii
20b Flowers largely stunted; at terminal parts of racemes sometimes normally arranged or more clustered; only the sterile remaining ovary is greatly enlarged. S. arvensis: Inducer unidentified – ? aphid
21a Flower buds enlarged, inflated, unopened. Corolla ± stunted. Stamens shortened and thickened. Containing several white, non-jumping larvae. S. alba, arvensis: Gephyraulus raphanistri
21b Galls similar. Larvae whitish to lemon-yellow, jumping. S. alba, arvensis: Contarinia nasturtii
22a Diseased flowers, with exception of stamens, often conspicuously enlarged. At first glossy, porcelain-like, soon bearing mealy dusted sori. Mainly occurring on single flowers; sometimes flower peduncle and midrib of galled inflorescence is also often elongated. S. alba, arvensis & subsp. allionii: Albugo candida
22b In the infected flowers, often inserted on short stalks, only the ovaries are hypertrophied, later on bearing down of branched conidiophores. All other organs ± strongly atrophied. Usually several to many flowers on the ± swollen and distorted axis of inflorescences are similarly galled, also covered with conidiophores. Galls partially contain oospores. S. alba & subsp. dissecta, arvensis & subsp. allionii: Hyaloperonospora brassicae