Ulmus elm
(For a dichotomous table for galls on Ulmus by Hans Roskam click here)
Dichotomous table for leafminers
1a corridor mine => 2
1b blotch mine => 8
1c tentiform mine => 13
1d fleck mine => 16
1e mine ends in an oval excision => 18
1c galls, etc => Tables for all parasites per species
Dichotomous table for leafminers
1a corridor mine => 2
1b blotch mine => 8
1c tentiform mine => 13
1d fleck mine => 16
1e mine ends in an oval excision => 18
1c galls, etc => Tables for all parasites per species
2a corridor < 15 mm; larva chamber relatively long => 3
2b corridor > 15 mm; larva chamber relatively shorter => 5
3a corridor proportionally broad => 4
3b corridor quite slender => 5
4a corridor follows midrib and/or a thick lateral vein, unbranched; most of the corridor completely filled with frass: Bucculatrix ulmifoliae
4b corridor winding freely, with 2-4 short, frass-free side branches; frass in a central line, leaving a clear zone at either side: Bucculatrix albedinella **
4c corridor winding freely, without side branches; southern species: Bucculatrix ulmicola
5a mine very compact, corridor densely wound => 6
5b corridor in wide loops, or following a vein or the leaf margin => 7
6a larva yellow; start of corridor a dense spiral: Stigmella lemniscella
6b larva bright green; start of corridor in a number of zigzagging loops: Stigmella viscerella
7a exit slit at upper surface; frass in first part of the corridor broadly dispersed Stigmella lemniscella
7b exit slit at lower surface; frass in first part of the corridor in a narrow line: Stigmella ulmivora
8a oviposition site (generally the leaf tip) covered with a shining black drop of hardened secretion: Trachys minutus
8b no such drop => 9
9a oviposition in the underside of the midrib of a thick lateral vein, leaving a clear scar; from there an initially narrow, later quite broad corridor running towards the leaf margin; older mines easily tearing in => 10
9b no oviposition scar, no initial corridor => 11
10a mine in May-June; oviposition generally in the midrib: Orchestes alni
10b mine in July-August; oviposition generally in a lateral vein: Orchestes betuleti
11a blotch containing generally several pink larvae; under the mine a loose spinning, in which grains of frass are hanging: Atemelia torquatella
11b blotch with 1 whitish larvae; no spinning under the mine => 12
12a on Ulmus laevis and minor; mine usually starts at the leaf margin: Fenusa altenhoferi
12b on Ulmus glabra; mine always starts in the centre of the leaf: Fenusa ulmi
13a pupa in a flimsy cocoon => 14
13b pupa in a tough, almost parchmentaceous, cocoon => 15
14a cremaster spines rather weak, outer pair bent backwards: Phyllonorycter agilella
14b cremaster spines very weak, out pair not bent backwards: Phyllonorycter acaciella
14c pupa unknown; described from Rhodes: Phyllonorycter brunnea.
15a mine short, round or oval; pupa dark brown in a greenish cocoon: Phyllonorycter schreberella
15b mine long, tube-like, between two veins; pupa light brown in a brown cocoon: Phyllonorycter tristrigella
16a lobe case: Coleophora violacea
16b composite leaf case: Coleophora serratella (youth case)
16c tubular leaf case: Coleophora serratella (final case)
16d spatulate leaf case => 17
17a case of full grown larva 9-11.5 mm: Coleophora limosipennella
17b case finally 5-6 mm: Coleophora badiipennella
18a much frass is expelled from an opening at the very beginning of the mine (mostly in a vein axil): Coleophora limosipennella (youth mine)
18b frass remains in the mine: Coleophora badiipennella (youth mine)
** Very occasionally a Stigmella can show a pathological behaviour that resembles this: pseudo-Bucculatrix“
Not included in the key: Apterona gracilis; Ectoedemia preisseckeri; Orchestes quedenfeldtii; Stigmella ulmiphaga.